High Court Grants Permission for Greencroft Forest Legal Challenge

High Court Grants Permission for Greencroft Forest Legal Challenge

A High Court judge has granted permission for a legal challenge over the proposed Greencroft Forest scheme in County Durham.

The case has been brought by Lanchester Properties Ltd against the Forestry Commission’s decision to approve the 290-hectare project without requiring a full Environmental Impact Assessment.

The proposed development, located between Greencroft, Maiden Law, Lanchester and Iveston, would see up to 65 per cent of the site planted with Sitka Spruce as part of a commercial timber plantation.

Court Finds Environmental Concerns Arguable

The Court determined that it is arguable the Forestry Commission did not adequately consider the environmental sensitivity of the location. Particular concern relates to areas identified as medium and high sensitivity in landscape and heritage studies.

The scheme, advanced by investment firm True North in partnership with Apex Fund Administration, covers 290 hectares of farmland and has been described as one of the largest contiguous afforestation proposals in the UK in recent decades .

True North submitted its Environmental Impact Assessment screening application in January 2025. Lanchester Properties, part of the Lanchester Group, subsequently sought a judicial review after the Forestry Commission concluded that a full Environmental Impact Assessment was not required .

Community and Parish Council Concerns

Community groups, residents and local businesses have raised concerns about the scale of the single-species plantation and its potential impact on biodiversity, landscape character and heritage.

David Smith, Councillor at Lanchester Parish Council, said:

“We attended numerous meetings about the Greencroft Forest proposal and consistently raised our concerns, yet we do not feel those views were meaningfully taken into account. We also presented the response of Lanchester Parish Council at an open meeting in May 2024, which we were told would not form part of the decision-making process. To date, we have found no evidence in the public documentation that our submission was recorded or considered. For many residents, it felt as though the outcome had already been decided. As a parish council we feel that our submission, that of the County Council and the views of the local community need to form an essential part of the decision-making process, as required by UK Forestry Standard. In the documents provided by the Forestry Commission, there is no evidence that this has taken place.

“This is an area of high landscape value and long-standing agricultural heritage. The farmland in question has been worked responsibly by tenant farmers for generations, and the impact on those families and on the wider community has been significant. Our concerns have always centred on transparency, proper consultation and the need for decisions that genuinely reflect the character of the place and the people who live here. As this is an application supported by the Forestry Commission and determined internally by the Forestry Commission, we feel that there is a lack of independence in determining this application, and there has been a lack of external scrutiny” .

Statement from Lanchester Group Director

Caroline Cleary-MacArthur, director of the Lanchester Group, said:

“As both a director of a long-established local business and a resident of this community, I welcome the Court’s permission and look forward to the substantive hearing. Residents were not adequately informed about the true nature of this scheme, nor that it would be dominated by an industrial timber forest of predominantly Sitka Spruce. People were led to believe this was a biodiversity project when the evidence shows otherwise.

“What we want is simple: transparency, proper environmental scrutiny and decisions that respect both the landscape and the community living within it. This permission ruling paves the way for our argument that the principle that large-scale developments of this kind must be subject to full and robust assessment. As taxpayers, we call for proper scrutiny of which privately run, offshore projects are deemed viable for Government funding.”

What Happens Next

A full substantive hearing will now determine whether the Forestry Commission’s original decision was lawful. The outcome could have wider implications for how large-scale afforestation schemes are assessed and approved across the UK.

Filed under Local News

Six primary school children, three boys and three girls, smile at the camera, with two holding a book award, in front of a large group of other students.Up nextAward-winning County Durham school heading to the ‘Oscars’ of teachingContinue reading →

Your story belongs on Consett Magazine

A new place, an award, a team that did something good: send it in. It is free, and an editor reads every story.

Send your story

More from Consett Magazine

All stories